Crow Hunt Quandary, Part Two

three-crows

 

By Maddy Butcher Gray

 

Last month, the simmering tension between diverse wildlife interests came to a boil as birders, nature lovers, and photographers squared off with hunters and the Wildlife Board.

At stake, the future of Utah’s crow population.

The Board voted to initiate a crow hunt for the first time in state history. Listen to the hearing.

The uproar continued.

Now, the board has another historical first: it will consider comments after having voted a proposal into law. It may keep it, toss it, or amend it.

Why all the hubbub?

Wildlife Board Coordinator, Staci Coons, told me the board is “obligated to consider the science behind a hunt as well as the social implications and public consensus.”

It appears the board is struggling to keep in line with its mission:

The Science:

At the June hearing, Utah Wildlife’s Blair Stringham and Mike Linell of Utah’s Wildlife Services (an agency of the US Department of Agriculture) outlined the reasons for the proposed hunt:

  • They stated crow populations have increased and certain farmers north of Salt Lake City have voiced complaints.
  • They stated crows have a significant impact on agriculture, including the habit of pecking the eyes of newborn calves and lambs.
  • They stated nearly every other state has a crow hunt, so Utah should, too.

Listen to the hearing here.

 

Examination of these statements reveals serious inaccuracies:

 

Utah is, in fact, the only state in the country with a “very low abundance” of American crows, according to the most respected data collection source, the USGS Patuxent Wildlife Research Center.

 

 

 crowchart

This chart indicates the crow population from 1987 to 2013, according to the National Audobon Society Christmas Bird Count. It indicates a high of more than 8,000 crows in 2004. 

 

According to another respected source, Audobon’s Christmas Bird Count, crows here peaked in 2004 and have been in steady decline ever since. Ten years ago, there were nearly 8,400 spotted; last year there were just 1,800.

It is true that most other states have crow hunts. But other states have more crows. Washington counted 26,000 last year; Oregon had 19,000. My home state, Maine (about a third the size of Utah) spotted 12,000.

Dr. Kevin McGowan of Cornell University’s Laboratory of Ornithology is one of the country’s foremost crow experts.

I asked him about the eye-pecking.

“That’s bulls&%*,” he said. “It has no bearing on reality. Crows eat small invertebrates and small vertebrates. They’re after bugs, lizards, mice, those sort of things.”

It appears the board has chosen to ignore the science and the social consensus against crow hunting, leaving one to draw just one conclusion:

We’re having a Utah crow hunt because it is something novel to shoot. But since most folks can’t tell the difference between black birds. Many ravens, magpies, grackles and blackbirds may fall victims, said board member Bill Fenimore, one of two who voted against the proposal. “It’s something that has rattled the bird community,” he said.

Did you know?

Crow hunters attract crows by using a distress call. It attracts more crows since they tend to mob as a form of survival and group protection.

“Hunters use these good family values against them,” said McGowan.

Ravens are far more common in Utah and may likely be the culprit to more agricultural damage (like eye-pecking).

Read Part One

 

 

Photo: Junior Libby / Three Black Crows / http://www.publicdomainpictures.net

Reposted, with permission, from Utah Outsider.com  To read this in the original, click here.

 

Public hearing: A special public hearing on the crow hunt has been called and will be held on Tuesday, July 29,  in Salt Lake City at the DNR Salt Lake office auditorium, 1594 West north Temple, Salt Lake City, from 10 am – 12 noon. Please attend if you can.

 

How to comment on the crow hunt

The comment period is for Utah residents only. Please indicte along with your signature that you are a Utah resident.

Please send a polite comment, in your own words, before July 29, to

Stacy Coons

UDWR Wildlife Coordinator

by phone at 801-538-4718

by FAX at 801-538-4709

or by email to stacicoons@utah.gov

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: