Crow Hunt Quandary, Part One

one-black-crow

 

By Maddy Butcher Gray

 

To understand the current brouhaha surrounding Utah’s pending crow hunt, it helps to know about the North American Model of Wildlife Conservation. The model was referred to several times at the Utah’s Wildlife Board public hearing, where the board voted 3-2 in favor of the crow hunt.

It derives from an 1842 Supreme Court case which addressed hunting, wildlife, and set in motion the placement of wildlife into public trust.

In a nutshell, that’s how we’ve gone from Open Season on Everything (circa early 1800’s) to protected species, endangered species, and hunted species with seasons, bag limits, etc. etc.

Sportsmen have, for over a century, had a seat at the wildlife management table. They didn’t get it for free. In Utah, the hook and bullet contingent supports 94 percent of the state’s wildlife department budget with its licenses, taxes on ammunition, duck stamps, and the like. Read more here.

As recently as 25 years ago, this sportsmen-government arrangement jibed well with the population. Back then, “every pickup had a shotgun in its rack and every kid had a big rodeo belt buckle” recalled Bill Fenimore, a Wildlife Board member and an award-winning birder.

In 2014, however, scads of Utahns aim only with a camera or pair of binoculars. Many of them showed up at the public hearing.

Blair Stringham, Migratory Game Bird Coordinator for the Division of Wildlife Resources, said the crow hunt idea originated internally and was sent out to the Regional Advisory Councils for comment sessions.

It was approved by four of the five RACs.

But at the state hearing, more wildlife watchers than hunters showed up. This makes sense since, according to the most recent US Fish & Wildlife survey on fishing, hunting, and wildlife-associated recreation (2011), that population now outnumbers the hunters and anglers combined. Of the 1.2 million Utahns getting outside, just 15 percent of them are hunters. Two-thirds are wildlife watchers.

So why was the crow hunt approved?

Follow the money.

As derived from the North American Model of Wildlife Conservation, billions are funneled from sportsmen and women to state and federal wildlife agencies. For generations, these folks were pretty much the only ones tromping through woods, wading through streams and attending hearings.

Only recently have non-consumptive parties asked to be part of the decision-making dance.

For the first time in state history and in response to public outcry, the Wildlife Board has scheduled a public hearing after their vote to institute the crow hunt. It’s a shining example of the shifting dynamics of wildlife interests and how non-consumptive parties are asking to be part of the process.

But given their lack of contributing dollars, how can wildlife watchers obtain a greater stakeholder status?

  • Charge a birdwatching season pass?
  • Charge hikers an access pass?
  • Tax binoculars, cameras and water bottles?

All absurd, of course.

Incorporating this growing population is “one of our biggest challenges,” said Stringham, who said many different options, including an access license, have been considered. (Generating funds through dedicated vehicle license plates has had limited success here.)

The model, for so long a pillar of what worked for wildlife, is coming under strain in Utah and elsewhere.

“To be a good conservationist, you don’t have to shoot things,” said Fenimore, “Now we have a lot of people interested in wildlife but without ranching backgrounds. The department is struggling to answer the question of how to ask that girl out for a date.”

To be sure, especially if she’s picking up the tab.

Read Part Two

 

Photo: Junior Libby / One Black Crow / http://www.publicdomainpictures.net 

Re-posted, with permission, from Utah Outsider.com. To read this in the original, click here.  

 

Public hearing: A special public hearing on the crow hunt has been called and will be held on Tuesday, July 29, in Salt Lake City at the DNR Salt Lake office auditorium, 1594 West North Temple, Salt Lake City, from 10am – 12 noon. Please attend if you can.

How to comment on the crow hunt

The comment period is for utah residents only. please indicate, along with your signature that you are a Utah resident.

Please send a polite comment, in your own words, before July 29, to

Staci Coons

UDWR Wildlife Coordinator

by phone at 801-538-4718

by FAX at 801-538-4709

or by email to stacicoons@utah.gov

 

Advertisements
3 comments
  1. Buz Marthaler said:

    Sharon,

    Did this article mean to say “women”? (“billions are funneled from sportsmen and women to state and federal wildlife agencies”) That bit was confusing to me as it didn’t seem to explain.

    Buz Marthaler

    Chairman, Board of Directors

    Wildlife Rehabilitation Center of Northern Utah 801-866-7503

    http://www.WRCNU.org

    WRC Osprey Logo 1.6 x 1

    Through wildlife rehabilitation and education we will empower

    the community to engage in conservation and responsible

    stewardship of wildlife and habitat.

    P Please consider the environment before printing this email or any attachments

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: